Vegan S’mores: An Update to a Campfire Classic
This post may contain affiliate links.
Nothing captures the essence of camping like a classic s’more. The simple yet ingenious recipe for a “marshmallow graham cracker sandwich” dates back to the early 1920’s, and was officially published in 1929 in the handbook Tramping and Trailing with the Girl Scouts. And since then, s’mores have been enjoyed by millions of campers all over the world.
So why make a vegan version of this campfire tradition? Why mess with success? It’s a worthy question. While we are anything but food purists, we have to respect any recipe that has remained relatively unchanged for nearly a century. But perhaps the better question is: why aren’t s’mores vegan to begin with?
Crunchy graham crackers, toasted marshmallows, and just-starting-to-melt chocolate. These are the hallmark features of a great s’more, however, there really isn’t anything here that necessitates the use of animal products. It’s certainly not central to the flavor profile, so is it really essential? So we took a look at why traditional s’mores contain animal product in the first place and explore a few options to make them vegan.
Graham Crackers: The original graham cracker was invented by Reverend Graham in 1829 and didn’t contain any sweetener at all. Over the years, the graham cracker has grown progressively sweeter – becoming more like a cookie than a cracker. Now, nearly every graham cracker manufacturer uses honey as at least one of its sweeteners (i.e. Honey Maid). In our opinion, this doesn’t need to be the case. While there are some accidently vegan graham crackers on the market, like Nabisco’s Original Grahams, there are also some more intentionally vegan version as well. We picked up a box of Smoreables Graham Crackers from Whole Foods for this recipe (these are also gluten free).
Marshmallows: You might not expect it, but marshmallows have actually been around since ancient Egypt, where sap from the marshmallow plant would be extracted, whipped, and sweetened. It wasn’t until the late 1800’s that French confectioner-industrialists started using gelatin in their recipes to make it easier for them to mass-produce their product. Thankfully, you don’t need melted horse hoof byproduct in order to make delicious, fluffy marshmallows (actually you never did). While there are a variety of vegan marshmallow options out there, the one we’ve been enjoying the most are Dandies. They’re everything you expect out a of marshmallow: light, fluffy, sweet. If you’re accustomed to the flavor and texture of a standard JetPuff marshmallow, we guarantee you’re not sacrificing anything by switching to Dandies.
Chocolate: While Hershey Chocolate Company has tried their best to convince the world that milk chocolate is essential to making a s’more, the historical text suggests otherwise. The original 1929 recipe from Tramping and Trailing with the Girl Scouts calls for “plain chocolate” and then further clarifies “from any of the good plain brands”. Now in terms of chocolate, this is a pretty broad definition, but thankfully you’ve got tons of “good brands” to choose from. If you’ve become attached to the light and creamy flavor of milk chocolate, there are some great vegan alternatives that use rice milk, coconut milk, and almond milk. Or, if you’re like us, and prefer the taste of dark chocolate instead then it is even easier to find a vegan chocolate bar. For this recipe we picked up a bar of 72% dark chocolate from Endangered Species brand, which donates 10% of their net profits to animal protection charities.
So there you have it: a classic vegan s’more. It’s just as delicious as a non-vegan s’more, but with 100% less animal product. So unless you feel really strongly about eating gelatin (we don’t) then there’s no reason not to give this version a try
- 2 vegan marshmallows
- 2 vegan graham crackers
- 2 squares dark chocolate
- Place the marshmallows on a stick or long metal skewer and roast over your campfire until browned on all sides.
- Break a graham cracker in half. Place a square of dark chocolate on one half, and top with one of the roasted marshmallows. Place the other graham cracker half on top. Repeat for the second s'more.
Nutrition (Per Serving)
Big thanks to Dandies for making this post possible. We’ve been fans of their marshmallows for some time, and we were stoked to have the opportunity to collaborate with them.
Love the little smores history lesson 🙂 Ive never seen those graham crackers before, I’ll have to look a little harder! and Dandies are definitely the best vegan mallows! I like that they have more of a more vanilla flavor than traditional mallows – yum!
We’ve seen the s’moreable graham crackers at a few different Whole Foods, but not in any mainstream supermarkets, so that might be a good place to look!
Smores are amazing!
Although my camping experience is not that vast I am sure they taste way better in an adventure, and this is a great option!
I have another recipe for you guys that can be made anywhere. It is a Brazilian recipe I am really proud of, and think everybody should learn. You only need a pan, spoons and 3 ingredients!
this is such a great article and I really like this so much
Love how you talked us through it. No argument from me- vegan s’mores all the way.
S’mores are the best part of camping!
Smoreables “May contain eggs” !
Just checked their product website and it certainly is confusing. They simultaneously state that the product is vegan, say “No eggs” and then also say “may contain eggs” – which are not in the ingredient list. It’s possible they have to put that in the fine print if they process in the same facility as eggs since they are an allergen.
Peta does list them as a vegan graham cracker as well: https://www.peta.org/living/food/vegan-graham-crackers/
Anyway, clear as mud!
I had trouble getting the Dandies to melt enough for s’mores, any tips?
We’re the “stick the marshmallow into the fire” types, so that may have helped? It’s possible that if you’re holding the marshmallow higher up and relying just on radiant heat it might not melt as well.